User blog comment:Asnow89/2015 Battle of the Fantasy Foods - Round FOUR/@comment-82.34.238.166-20150825163105/@comment-108.230.40.127-20150825164938

Nah, it's because Steven Universe and Gravity Falls have been around less than 4 years, versus Spongebob's 16 years and the Elder Scrolls series' 21 years. Way more people have at least heard about the two, and so there's probably a lot of people who don't know what Cookie Cats or Mabel Juice are, and are going with the more recognizable options.

That, and "Mabel Juice" sounds mildly disturbing to me. I almost hate to ask what's in it.